Editor's Note: This article was adapted from an article authored by Chris Peters in March 2009.
Microsoft's server licensing can be complicated. Do you need a client access license (CAL)? If so, should it be a user CAL or a device CAL? And should your CAL operate in per-server or per-seat mode? If choosing licenses for your Microsoft products is making your head spin, our guide to Microsoft server and client licensing is here to help.
We'll cover licenses for server software, licenses for clients, and some advanced Microsoft licensing scenarios. And while this article focuses on Microsoft server applications, similar issues can arise with other server applications.
Licenses for Server Software
The license required to install and run most server applications usually comes bundled with the software itself. So you can install and run most applications "out of the box," as long as you have the right number of client licenses and meet the server licensing requirements. More detail on client licensing is provided below.
In some cases, though, you may need additional licenses in order to run your server software:
- Every time you install server software (on a physical server or a virtual one), you create an "instance" of that application. The number of "instances" of a particular application that you can run using a single license varies from product to product.
- With "per processor" or "per core" or licensing, the amount of server licenses needed depends on the number of processors or processor cores on which the server software runs. In some cases, only physical processors or cores need to be licensed, while virtual processors or cores must be licensed for certain products. For example, Windows Server 2012 uses per-processor licensing, with each server license covering up to two physical processors on a server.
For more information about server licensing, read TechSoup's Guide to Microsoft Server Licensing, which contains links to guides on licensing specific Microsoft server products.
Licenses for Clients
Depending on the licensing scenario, "clients" can be either the end users themselves (employees, contractors, clients, and anyone else who uses the software in question) or their computing devices (for example, laptops, desktop computers, smartphones, tablets, etc.).
There are a few things to think about when you're planning for client licenses.
User CALs or Device CALs?
- User CALs allow each user access to all the instances of a particular server product in an organization, no matter which device they use to gain access. This means each user can access the server software from as many devices as they want (for example, from a desktop, laptop, or smartphone). User CALs are the more common licensing option.
- Device CALs allow access to all instances of a particular server product from a single device (a laptop or a desktop computer, for example), regardless of how many people use that device. Device CALs are less common that user CALs, but they do make sense when multiple employees use the same computer. For example, in 24-hour call centers, different employees on different shifts often use the same machine, so device CALs make sense in that situation.
Per User/Per Device or Per Server Licensing Mode?
With Windows Server, you use a CAL in one of two licensing modes: per user/per device (sometimes referred to as "per seat") or per server. You make this decision when you're installing your Windows Server products, not when you acquire the CALs. The CALs themselves don't have any mode designation, so you can use either kind of CAL in either licensing mode.
- Per user/per device or "per seat" mode is the default mode, and the one used most frequently. In this mode, you need one CAL per user or device that will be accessing the server software, regardless of the number of servers being accessed.
- In per server mode, you are allowed a specified maximum number of simultaneous connections to the server. In other words, if you have 40 CALs, Windows will let 40 authenticated users have access. The 41st user will be denied access. Per server mode works for some small charities and organizations with one or two servers and limited access requirements.
Some Key Points About Client Licensing
- Do your reading — Make sure you read the product descriptions and any other available documentation carefully to make sure you understand all the details about licensing a particular application.
- You don't always need CALs — Not all server-based software requires CALs. Although many Microsoft products — including Windows Server — do require CALs, SQL Server and other products don't require any client licenses. Software licensed with a processor license usually doesn't require CALs either.
- You need only User CALs or Device CALs, not both — For example, you don't need to get a user CAL for yourself and a device CAL for your computer. And while legally you can use a mix of the two different types of licenses, it's not recommended in most situations.
- You often get a few administrative client licenses — Microsoft server products always include one or two client licenses for administrative use so you or your IT staff can access, configure, and troubleshoot the software.
- Client apps don't come with client licenses — Client licenses aren't bundled with the standard Microsoft client applications. They have to be obtained separately, even when there seems to be a natural connection between two types of software. For example, Microsoft Outlook (an email client application) doesn't come with a client license for Microsoft Exchange (an email server application).
- Consider CAL suites — If you need CALs for several different Microsoft products, see if there are CAL suites available. For example, Microsoft Core User CAL Suites and Core Device CAL Suites are available through TechSoup donations. These suites bundle together CALs and other licenses for several Microsoft server technologies.
- You often need multiple licenses per client — A single client (either a person or machine) often needs multiple licenses when accessing one physical server. For example, if you use your desktop computer to access a SharePoint Server on a Windows Server machine, you have to have a client license for both products.
- Pay attention to the Microsoft donation program rules — For example, there is a 50-license maximum for Microsoft title groups that contain client access licenses or other licenses that provide for connection to or management of a server. There is a five-product maximum for server products, regardless of title group. For further details, see Quantity and Frequency of Microsoft Requests on the Microsoft Donation Program — Eligibility and Allotments page.
Advanced Microsoft Licensing Scenarios
The licensing scenarios described in this section are less common, so we'll cover them only briefly. The Additional Resources section provides more information on these advanced scenarios.
- Client licenses for external users — If you have any authenticated external users who need to access services on your Windows-based servers, you have several options: You can obtain CALs for each user who needs to access your servers. Or you can acquire a single External Connector License (ECL) that covers the server they will be accessing. The ECL covers use of that server by all authenticated external users, but it's a lot more expensive than a CAL, so only get one if you'll have a lot of external users. If only a handful of external users access your Windows servers, you're better off acquiring user CALs.
- Windows Remote Desktop Services (RDS) licensing — Windows Remote Desktop Services (formerly known as Windows Terminal Services) is built into Windows Server, but you will still need to get a separate Windows RDS User CAL for each client that will access Terminal Services in your charity or organization. The RDS CAL replaces the older Terminal Services (TS) CAL.
- Standard CALs and Enterprise CALs — Some Microsoft server products have two client licensing modes, standard and enterprise. An Enterprise CAL grants access to more advanced features of a product. With some products, a user needs both a Standard CAL and an Enterprise CAL in order to access the advanced features.
- CALs for Dynamics CRM — Microsoft's Dynamics CRM products (for customer relationship management) have five different types of CALs, some of which are "additive," meaning they need to be used in conjunction with another CAL. See TechSoup's Guide to Dynamics CRM Editions and Licensing for more information.
- Licenses for System Center products — Microsoft's System Center products (a line of enterprise-level administrative software packages) generally use a special type of license known as a management license (ML). Any desktop or workstation managed by one of these applications needs a client management license. Any server managed by one of these applications requires a server management license. For more information, see TechSoup's Guide to System Center Products and Licensing.